Half of Consumers Would Switch Retailers for a Coupon: Survey Insight

Half of Consumers Would Switch Retailers for a Coupon: Survey Insight

In today’s fast-paced retail environment, understanding what drives consumer purchasing decisions is more critical than ever. A recent survey by Valpak and PureSpectrum, conducted with over 500 shoppers, reveals a clear trend: deals and discounts are the key motivators behind where consumers choose to spend their money. From big-box giants to niche stores like GameStop, the data shows that nearly half of shoppers are ready to switch retailers if offered a coupon—a powerful insight for businesses aiming to capture market share.

Why Shoppers Choose or Switch Retailers: Price Rules the Day

When it comes to deciding where to shop, affordability tops the list of priorities. The survey pinpointed the top five reasons consumers try new retailers or abandon old ones:

  • Low Cost (65%): Price is the ultimate deciding factor, with most shoppers seeking the best value for their dollar.
  • Coupons and Offers (45%): Nearly half of respondents highlighted promotional deals as a major incentive, aligning with the survey’s headline finding.
  • Great Customer Service (39%): A positive shopping experience still matters, influencing over a third of consumers.
  • Store Loyalty/Rewards Programs (38%): Loyalty perks encourage repeat business and sway retailer choices.
  • Customer Reviews (37%): Peer feedback plays a role in building trust and guiding decisions.

These findings showcase a price-sensitive market where retail discounts and incentives like coupons can tip the scales, making them essential tools for retailers looking to attract new customers and retain existing ones.

Most Desired Retail Offers: BOGO Reigns Supreme

Consumers aren’t shy about what they want from retailers—deals that deliver real savings. The survey identified the top five most requested retail offers:

  • Buy One, Get One Free (72%): This crowd-pleaser leads the pack, appealing to shoppers’ love for instant value.
  • Marked-Down Items (65%): Discounts on individual products are a close second, proving markdowns are a retail must-have.
  • Rewards/Loyalty Discounts (54%): Over half of consumers crave perks for their continued patronage.
  • Storewide Sales (50%): Broad discounts across a store’s inventory draw significant interest.
  • Seasonal Sales (50%): Timed promotions capitalize on shopping trends throughout the year.

These preferences signal that shopper motivations hinge on tangible savings, with promotions like BOGO and loyalty discounts standing out as prime opportunities for retailers to boost engagement and sales.

How Shoppers Want to Receive Offers: Email Still Leads

In an age of digital innovation, the survey asked consumers how they prefer to get their retail offers. The top five channels emerged as:

  • Email (59%): The go-to method for nearly three-fifths of shoppers, email remains a powerhouse for delivering deals.
  • Direct Mail (49%): Traditional mailers hold strong, appealing to almost half of respondents.
  • Text Messages (35%): Quick and convenient, SMS offers resonate with over a third of consumers.
  • Company Websites (19%): A smaller but notable group prefers browsing retailer sites for promotions.
  • Social Media (12%): Platforms like Facebook and Instagram lag behind but still reach a niche audience.

This mix of digital and physical channels underscores the need for a multi-faceted approach to reach today’s shoppers effectively. Retailers leveraging coupons and offers through email and mail can maximize visibility and response rates.

Personalized Offers That Win Hearts

Personalization is transforming retail, and consumers have clear preferences for tailored promotions. The survey highlighted the top five personalized offers shoppers crave:

  • Loyal Customer Offers (61%): Rewarding fidelity tops the list, with over three-fifths wanting exclusive perks.
  • Birthday Offers (59%): Special discounts for personal milestones are a hit with nearly as many.
  • Seasonal Offers (59%): Timely deals tied to seasons keep shoppers engaged.
  • Holiday Offers (57%): Festive promotions are a close fourth, driving holiday spending.
  • Anniversary Offers (33%): Celebrating customer milestones appeals to a smaller but dedicated segment.

These insights reveal that personalized offers can deepen customer relationships, turning one-time buyers into loyal advocates through targeted, meaningful discounts.

The Takeaway: Discounts Are Non-Negotiable

Gone are the days when price-conscious shoppers lingered only in clearance aisles. Today’s consumers demand authentic, upfront savings—and they’re not afraid to switch retailers to get them. The Valpak and PureSpectrum survey debunks the myth that discounting cheapens a brand; instead, it proves that strategic deals enhance appeal. With half of consumers willing to switch retailers for a coupon, businesses ignoring this trend risk losing ground.

Actionable Strategies for Retailers

To thrive, retailers should:

  • Prioritize Low Prices: Competitive costing is non-negotiable in a value-driven market.
  • Offer Irresistible Deals: BOGO, markdowns, and loyalty discounts top shoppers’ wish lists.
  • Leverage Multi-Channel Delivery: Email and direct mail lead, but texts and websites broaden reach.
  • Embrace Personalization: Tailored offers like birthday and loyalty rewards build lasting connections.

By aligning with these consumer purchasing decisions, retailers can turn price-savvy shoppers into loyal customers, ensuring growth in a fiercely competitive landscape.

Back to blog